How to Get Broadway Show Tickets Last Minute – Tips for Hard-to-Get Shows & Hidden Gems

Overview

Getting tickets to some Broadway shows can be as challenging as climbing Mount Everest, while others offer a more accessible yet equally enjoyable experience. Securing Broadway show tickets last minute can feel like a game of chance, especially when you’re aiming for the most popular productions. But with the right strategy, patience, and a bit of luck, you can find yourself sitting in the audience of a top-tier show, even at the last moment. Here’s a comprehensive guide on both the shows that are notoriously hard to get tickets for and some underrated gems where you have a better chance of snagging Broadway show tickets last minute.

Shows with Hard-to-Get Tickets

These shows are typically sold out or have high demand, making it difficult to secure Broadway show tickets last minute, especially for weekend performances. If you’re set on seeing one of these blockbuster productions, it’s best to plan ahead. However, there are still strategies you can employ if you’re hoping to score last-minute seats to these fan favorites.

1. Hamilton

Lin-Manuel Miranda’s hip-hop-infused retelling of Alexander Hamilton’s life continues to draw massive crowds. Since its debut, it has remained one of Broadway’s most sought-after tickets. Even years after its premiere, people line up hoping for cancellations or last-minute releases, making Broadway show tickets last minute for Hamilton almost a rarity. Tickets are often booked months in advance, and prices can be sky-high due to its high demand.

• Pro Tip: Enter the Hamilton digital lottery for a chance to win heavily discounted tickets. The lottery offers $10 tickets, and while competition is fierce, it’s still a viable option for scoring seats without breaking the bank.

2. The Book of Mormon

This irreverent and hilarious musical by the creators of “South Park” remains a top choice for both Broadway newcomers and seasoned theatergoers. With its witty humor and unforgettable songs, The Book of Mormon continues to sell out regularly, especially for weekend performances. Scoring Broadway show tickets last minute for this show can be tough but not impossible.

• Best Strategy: Try for standing room tickets, which are sometimes released on the day of the performance. It’s a more affordable way to catch the show if you don’t mind standing through the performance.

3. Wicked

This retelling of The Wizard of Oz from the witches’ perspective has been a Broadway staple for years. It’s family-friendly, appeals to a wide range of audiences, and features some of the most spectacular sets and costumes on Broadway. Due to its popularity, getting Broadway show tickets last minute for Wicked can be challenging, particularly for evening and weekend shows.

• Pro Tip: Look into matinee performances or weekday evening shows. These are often less crowded, and you may have a better chance of finding last-minute availability.

4. The Lion King

Based on the Disney animated classic, The Lion King is one of the longest-running shows on Broadway. Its visually stunning production, coupled with beloved music by Elton John and Tim Rice, continues to captivate audiences of all ages. Given its enduring popularity, securing Broadway show tickets last minute for The Lion King can be particularly difficult, especially during the holidays and school vacation periods when families flock to see it.

• Best Bet: Try the TodayTix app or head to a TKTS booth for same-day discounted tickets. While it’s rare, last-minute releases do happen, especially for weekday performances.

5. MJ The Musical

A tribute to Michael Jackson’s life and music, MJ The Musical has quickly become a Broadway sensation, drawing fans from all over the world. The show’s energetic performances and iconic music have made it a hot ticket, often selling out weeks in advance. Finding Broadway show tickets last minute for this show can be a challenge, but it’s not impossible with the right approach.

• Pro Tip: Keep an eye on the TodayTix rush tickets or check for cancellations directly at the box office on the day of the show. Some seats might open up unexpectedly.

Underrated Shows with More Accessible Tickets

While the big-name shows often steal the spotlight, there are plenty of underrated Broadway productions where you can still enjoy an unforgettable experience without the stress of sold-out performances. These shows offer incredible performances, unique storytelling, and—most importantly—more availability when it comes to securing Broadway show tickets last minute.

1. Hadestown

This Tony Award-winning musical tells the story of Orpheus and Eurydice in a unique and captivating way. Its mixture of Greek mythology, folk music, and New Orleans jazz has garnered a dedicated following. Although Hadestown is gaining popularity, you can often find tickets with relative ease compared to the bigger blockbuster shows.

• Pro Tip: Look for weekday performances or use ticket apps like SeatGeek and StubHub to find last-minute deals for Hadestown.

2. Come From Away

This heartwarming musical tells the true story of how a small town in Newfoundland welcomed thousands of stranded passengers after the events of 9/11. With its moving story and uplifting performances, Come From Away is a hidden gem that hasn’t yet reached the sold-out status of other Broadway hits. This makes it a great option for those seeking Broadway show tickets last minute without the pressure of high demand.

• Pro Tip: TodayTix often offers rush or discounted tickets for Come From Away, especially for weekday shows.

3. Six

This high-energy musical retells the stories of Henry VIII’s six wives with a modern pop twist. Each wife sings about her unique experience with the infamous king, creating a fun and empowering narrative. Although Six has built a dedicated fan base, it’s not always sold out, making it easier to find Broadway show tickets last minute.

• Best Bet: Look for TKTS booth tickets or try the TodayTix rush feature for last-minute seats.

4. The Play That Goes Wrong

If you’re in the mood for comedy, The Play That Goes Wrong offers a hilarious experience full of slapstick humor and chaotic mishaps. While not as high-profile as other Broadway comedies, this show provides an excellent night of laughter and is a great choice for securing Broadway show tickets last minute.

• Pro Tip: Check out Goldstar or other discount ticket platforms for deals on same-day performances of this comedy favorite.

5. To Kill a Mockingbird

Based on the classic novel by Harper Lee, this play has received critical acclaim and features top-notch performances, including the role of Atticus Finch. Despite its quality, To Kill a Mockingbird has remained somewhat under the radar, meaning tickets are generally easier to find compared to other high-profile shows.

• Best Strategy: Use apps like TodayTix or head to the box office for last-minute releases.

Tips for Scoring Broadway Show Tickets Last Minute

Whether you’re aiming for a blockbuster hit or a lesser-known production, the key to securing Broadway show tickets last minute is flexibility and persistence. Here are some strategies to improve your chances of getting into your desired show, even on short notice.

• Enter Lotteries: Many popular Broadway shows, including Hamilton, The Lion King, and Wicked, offer daily lotteries for a chance to win heavily discounted last-minute tickets. Entering multiple lotteries increases your odds of success.
• Try Standing Room Only (SRO) Tickets: Some shows release SRO tickets on the day of the performance. While you won’t have a seat, it’s a more affordable way to experience high-demand shows.
• Check TKTS Booths or Use Apps: For same-day tickets, head to a TKTS booth or use apps like TodayTix to find discounted Broadway show tickets last minute.

Final Thoughts

By considering these underrated shows, you can enjoy the Broadway experience without the frustration of sold-out performances. And if you’re determined to see one of the hard-to-get-ticket shows, remember to plan ahead, consider lotteries or standing room tickets, and explore authorized discount ticket sources. Whether you’re seeking tickets to a blockbuster or a hidden gem, there are always ways to secure Broadway show tickets last minute and enjoy the magic of live theater in New York City. Check out our great selection of Broadway show tickets last minute below!